Try a free month of being a Eurogamer Supporter
Sign up for a free trial and get ad-free browsing and exclusive content. Use code "Eurogamer1" at checkout.
As Persona actress leaves Twitter following AI dispute.
Paul Eiding, the voice of Metal Gear Solid’s Colonel Roy Campbell, has spoken out about the use of his vocal talents without permission, including by AI.
Eiding, who also voices characters in the Fallout series and Shin Megami Tensei 5, to name but a few, said that if someone does not have written permission to use his voice, then they “DO NOT HAVE PERMISSION”. This, the actor stated, included any AI voice lines generated using his voice data.
“Doing so is a violation of my legal rights and a real slap in the face,” Eiding wrote.
Eiding’s comments come after fellow Metal Gear actor David Hayter also expressed his disdain for AI technology.
“Anybody who steals your voice should be locked up for forever,” the Solid Snake actor told Eurogamer, adding that AI voice acting will always be soulless by comparison.
“If you think you’re going to get the thousands of subtle, emotional adjustments that [fellow voice actor] Jennifer Hale is going to give you word for word, you’re fooling yourself,” he said.
“Yes, legally, we should all be protected against these idiots trying to repurpose our voices for free, or our voices or images or writing, what have you. But technologically, I’m not terribly concerned, I think it’ll always be soulless.”
Please read.
If you do not have written permission to use my voice,
you DO NOT HAVE PERMISSION to use my voice,
including AI use. Doing so is a violation of my legal rights
and a real slap in the face.
Thanks in advance, for not doing this. #MGS #Transformers #Ben10 #Fallout
It is not just the Metal Gear Solid cast standing up against the illegal use of actors’ voices.
Erica Lindbeck, who voices characters such as Black Cat (Felicia Hardy) in Marvel’s Spider-Man and Cassie Cage in Mortal Kombat 11, has left Twitter following an online dispute with a content creator that used her voice in an AI-generated video.
As reported by TheGamer, Lindbeck’s voice was used in an AI-generated cover of Welcome to the Internet by Bo Burnham. The video showed the song being sung by Lindbeck’s Persona character, Futaba Sakura.
In reaction to this video, Lindbeck asked her followers to report any similar videos they see online.
In return, the AI creator accused Lindbeck of inciting a “harassing campaign” over a “dumb but harmless Futaba AI cover video”.
While it has not been specified precisely why, the creator of this AI video has now seen their Twitter account suspended for violating the platform’s media policy.
I stand with Erica Lindbeck.
VAs have a right to their own voices.
If you’re asked to take down AI replicating them, then kindly listen. Otherwise you are helping normalize the idea that artists don’t have a right to their own voices. https://t.co/W710mKui3i
For more on AI, be sure to check out Ed’s interview with other prolific voice actors such as Jane Perry and Troy Baker, where they discuss their scepticism of whether AI can truly replicate human performances and what its impact could be on the voice acting industry.
From Assassin's Creed to Zoo Tycoon, we welcome all gamers
Eurogamer welcomes videogamers of all types, so sign in and join our community!
Follow topics and we’ll email you when we publish something new about them. Manage your notification settings .
We’ll send you an email whenever we (or one of our sister sites) publish an article on this topic.
You can manage your preferences here .
Get the day's most talked about stories straight to your inbox.
Victoria Kennedy
News Reporter
Victoria developed a deep love for video games watching her brothers barrel their way through Goldeneye 007. She will unashamedly spout forth all sorts of niche Zelda lore to anyone who will listen (and even at times to those who won’t), and makes the best pancakes you have ever seen.
Please enable JavaScript to see comments.
Supporters | Five of the Best: Moustaches
Digital Foundry | PlayStation 3 emulation tested: revisiting Metal Gear Solid 4 at 4K 60fps with RPCS3
Dune and Star Wars' Oscar Isaac cast as Solid Snake in Metal Gear Solid movie
Sony sends off PS3 Plus games with Metal Gear Solid 4
David Hayter reprises Snake in this Metal Gear Solid tribute video
David Hayter reprises Metal Gear Solid role in Ford commercials
Review | Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots review
Feature | Metal Gear Solid 4: Rinse, repeat, resolve?
Hello Neighbor publisher outlines troubling future of employee monitoring in AI keynote
There's an official Assassin's Creed Mirage "haptic gaming suit" on the way
Larry "Major Nelson" Hryb departs Microsoft after 22 years
Atari's arcade classic Lunar Lander being reimagined with "deep narrative" for 2024
Xbox Game Pass Friends and Family preview ends next month, Microsoft confirms
Genshin Impact voice actors speak out over "inexcusable" lack of pay
Annapurna-published puzzler Lorelei and the Laser Eyes features a broken world and a big secret
This PlayStation pasta pushes all the right buttons
The latest video game jobs on GamesIndustry.biz
Buy things with globes on them
And other lovely Eurogamer merch in our official store!
Bad puns and video games since 1999.
Eurogamer.net is owned by Gamer Network Limited, a ReedPop company and subsidiary of Reed Exhibitions Limited.
© 2023 Gamer Network Limited, Gateway House, 28 The Quadrant, Richmond, Surrey, TW9 1DN, United Kingdom, registered under company number 03882481.
All rights reserved. No part of this website or its content may be reproduced without the copyright owner’s permission.
